• About Us
  • Contributors
  • Guides
  • Speaking Engagements
  • Write for The SEM Post
  • Submit a tip or contact us!
  • Newsletters

The SEM Post

Latest News About SEO, SEM, PPC & Search Engines

  • Google
  • SEO
  • Mobile
  • Local
  • Bing
  • Pay Per Click
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • State of the Industry
You are here: Home / SEO / Separating the SEO Signal from the Noise

Separating the SEO Signal from the Noise

February 19, 2015 at 4:39 am PST By Doc Sheldon

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • Email
  • WhatsApp
  • Evernote
  • SMS

state of the industry header

noisy-signalWith hundreds of voices clamoring to be heard, most professing to be God’s gift to SEO, it can seem impossible to figure out who to listen to. The fact that there is so much disagreement in what they all have to say makes it even tougher.

So how do you pick the right voice to heed?

 

There’s no universal formula for separating the wisdom from the BS. What works for you might not work for anyone else. But here are a few things you might want to consider when you’re trying to figure out whether someone’s opinion is worth considering.

Positives

  1. Do they offer any real evidence for their claims?
  2. Do they make it clear when they’re stating an opinion, that it’s only that?
  3. Do they listen to differing points of view?
  4. Are they objective, admitting that they may not know all the facts?

Negatives

  1. Do they cite “tests” or “experiments” that exhibit no more scientific approach than a coin toss?
  2. Do they try to bolster their own position by belittling that of others?

The first 4 points are positives… if the candidate exhibits those characteristics, it’s a plus in their favor. To me, these traits indicate a desire to present an even-handed argument, without misleading, while ensuring they’ve considered all reasonable possibilities.

The last two, at least for me, are show-stoppers. #5 is likely to show you correlation, while claiming it “proves” something. #6 should be a red flag… if that’s the best argument they can present, then they have no argument.

Gauging the value of their arguments

You won’t come across a single blog post or discussion thread by which you can bracket any individual as credible or not. It’s much more likely to be a trend that appears over a period of time and a variety of topics. When you’re spending a lot of time looking for opinions, you’ll find no shortage of them. Odds are that after you’ve seen a dozen or so such instances from an individual, you’ll get a pretty good feel for how reliable a source they may be.

A few “rules” that might be helpful, to help offset the more judgmental points above:

  • Years of experience count… but alone, it’s not enough to establish credibility. Young newcomers can sometimes bring a lot to the table. Conversely, old-timers can occasionally be total idiots.
  • A lack of visibility doesn’t equate to a lack of expertise. Just because someone rarely offers their opinion doesn’t mean they don’t have one. It also doesn’t mean they’re not brilliantly qualified… maybe they’re just shy. Or busy. Or not interested in sharing.
  • Just because everyone seems to disagree with them doesn’t mean they’re wrong. History abounds with innovators that swam against the current and were later proven to be right.
  • Just because everyone seems to agree with them doesn’t mean they’re right, either. The more notoriety one has, the fewer people are inclined to publicly disagree with them.
  • Someone can be the best there is at one part of SEO and totally worthless at another.
  • Nobody’s good at everything, so be fair when assessing someone’s capabilities

Often, recommendations from others that have used someone’s services or worked with them will be valuable. Still, we each have to sort through the noise and try to find the signal, and nothing can tell us with certainty how it’ll work out until we’ve actually tried their recommendations for ourselves.

Of course, if you still can’t decide who to listen to, you could just decide to take a radical approach and test your own theories. That way, if something doesn’t work out well, you’ll have nobody to blame but yourself.

The key is to apply critical thinking skills to your analysis. If you don’t possess those skills already, you’d better find a way to get them… without a doubt, they’re the most powerful tool in your kit.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • Email
  • WhatsApp
  • Evernote
  • SMS
The following two tabs change content below.
  • Bio
  • Latest Posts
My Twitter profileMy Facebook profileMy Google+ profileMy LinkedIn profileMy Instagram profile

Doc Sheldon

Doc Sheldon began studying SEO in earnest in 2003 and began offering SEO services part-time a couple of years later. In 2008, he retired from his business management consulting firm and began practicing SEO full-time. He concentrates on staying abreast of new and upcoming developments in search and writes extensively on technical SEO and semantic search. He manages his SEO consultancy, Intrinsic Value SEO, and his content agency, Top Shelf Copy, from his San Diego office, with U.S satellite offices in Missouri and Pennsylvania as well as in Australia and Great Britain. He also has alliances with several other SEOs, from which they offer international marketing services. Doc's passions are combating online misinformation and the Semantic Web. Oh, and he dislikes both beets and blended Scotch - passionately. You can see more of Doc's writing and connect with him on various social media platforms via his Google+ account.
My Twitter profileMy Facebook profileMy Google+ profileMy LinkedIn profileMy Instagram profile

Latest posts by Doc Sheldon (see all)

  • Just Another Pothole in an SEO Client Relationship - September 8, 2015
  • Are You Your Own Worst Enemy With Marketing? - June 17, 2015
  • Dear SEO Industry: Haters Don’t HAVE to Hate - March 31, 2015
  • Separating the SEO Signal from the Noise - February 19, 2015
  • Is SSL a Blackhole? Or is it the Event Horizon? - January 6, 2015

Filed Under: SEO, State of the Industry

Sign up for our newsletter


Trackbacks

  1. SearchCap: Google Mobile Carousel Update, Bing Online Ordering & AdWords Android App says:
    February 19, 2015 at 2:00 pm

    […] Separating the SEO Signal from the Noise, The SEM Post […]

Founder & Editor

Jennifer Slegg (2052)

Sign up for our daily news recap & weekly newsletter.


Follow us online

  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • Linkedin
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

Latest News

2022 Update for Google Quality Rater Guidelines – Big YMYL Updates

We finally have the first Google Quality Rater Guidelines update of 2022, and like usual, it is … [Read More...]

Recent Posts

  • 2022 Update for Google Quality Rater Guidelines – Big YMYL Updates
  • Google Quality Rater Guidelines: The Low Quality 2021 Update
  • Rethinking Affiliate Sites With Google’s Product Review Update
  • New Google Quality Rater Guidelines, Update Adds Emphasis on Needs Met
  • Google Updates Experiment Statistics for Quality Raters
  • Analyzing “How Google Search Works” Changes from Google
  • Google Quality Rater Guidelines Update: New Introduction, Rater Bias & Political Affiliations
  • Google Updates Quality Rater Guidelines: Reputation for News Sites; Video Content Updates; Quality for Information Sites
  • Google Makes Major Changes to NoFollow, Adds Sponsored & UGC Tags
  • Google Updates Quality Rater Guidelines Targeting E-A-T, Page Quality & Interstitials

Categories

  • Affiliate Marketing
  • Amazon
  • Apple
  • Bing
  • Branding
  • Browsers
  • Chrome
  • Content Marketing
  • Design
  • Domains
  • DuckDuckGo
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Firefox
  • Foursquare
  • Google
    • Analytics
    • Google RankBrain
    • Quality Rater's Guidelines
  • History of Search
  • Industry Spotlight
  • Instagram
  • Internet Explorer
  • Links
  • Local
  • Mobile
  • Native Advertising
  • Other Search Engines
  • Pay Per Click
  • Pinterest
  • Publishers
  • Security
  • SEO
  • Snapchat
  • Social Media
  • State of the Industry
  • The SEM Post
  • Tools
  • Twitter
  • Uncategorized
  • User Experience
  • Video Marketing
  • Week in Review
  • Whitepapers
  • Wordpress
  • Yahoo
  • Yelp
  • YouTube
February 2023
MTWTFSS
« Aug  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728 

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries RSS
  • Comments RSS
  • WordPress.org

Copyright © 2023 · News Pro Theme On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in